• Contact
  • Helpdesk
DARIAHDARIAHDARIAHDARIAH
  • About
    • DARIAH in a Nutshell
    • Mission & Vision
    • Organisation and Governance
    • Join DARIAH
    • History of DARIAH
    • Documents
    • Publications
  • Network
    • Members and Partners
    • Regional Hubs
    • People
  • Activities
    • Working Groups
    • Training and Education
    • Open Science
      • DARIAH Open
      • OpenMethods
      • Heritage Data Reuse Charter
    • Projects
    • DARIAH Theme
  • Tools & Services
    • Tools and Services
    • Contributions
  • News & Events
    • News
    • Events Calendar
    • Annual Events
    • Newsletters

Who needs directories: A forum on sustaining discovery portals large and small

Home News
NextPrevious

Who needs directories: A forum on sustaining discovery portals large and small

By Eliza Papaki | News | July 30, 2020

In fall 2019, Laure Barbot, Quinn Dombrowski, Frank Fischer, Geoffrey Rockwell, and Lisa Spiro submitted the following proposal to the DH 2020 conference “Who Needs Tool Directories? A Forum on Sustaining Discovery Portals Large and Small”. As everything turned into virtual, this “forum” was also organised as a virtual forum, setting up a website to accommodate these exchanges: https://dh2020directoriesforum.hcommons.org/

The proposal 

Digital humanists broadly agree that tool directories are a good and valuable thing, worth building and maintaining, but there is no sustainability model. This forum aims to move beyond platitudes and interrogate the value of directories and possible models for sustaining them. For whom are tool directories valuable, and in what context?

Tool directories require ongoing attention in order to remain relevant — and more technically sophisticated directories face infrastructure maintenance costs as long as the directory remains online and functional. Some directories have adopted a crowdsourcing model to address content updates, translation, and other necessary functions once grant funding runs out. As unpaid labor increasingly becomes an area of attention and concern for digital humanities, one is left to ask, how ethical are directories, particularly when this volunteer labor is at particular risk of being lost through fragile infrastructure? At a certain point, time and funding are a zero-sum game: are directories actually worth it?

This forum is organized by individuals representing a range of DH directories, spanning from 2002 (Geoffrey Rockwell’s TAPoR) to 2020 (Frank Fischer and Laure Barbot representing the Marketplace developed within the SSHOC project), along with the defunct DiRT (Lisa Spiro and Quinn Dombrowski). 

The forum will help the organizers grapple with the difficult decisions that fall out from the “directory paradox”, where the DH community’s praise of directories is wildly incommensurate with the interest or resources available for sustaining them. Similarly, they aim to help others running directories at various scales (including in forms such as Libguides or lists on GitHub pages) return to their projects with a clearer sense of what they’re doing, for whom, why, and for how long.

If you want to be part of this discussion, simply visit the site and leave your comments on the set of questions you will find there! An online discussion session will be organised later in August: stay tuned!

No tags.

Related Post

  • Visual Media and Interactivity: DARIAH Working Group Started a Platform to Collect and Discuss Tools

    By dariah

    The DARIAH working group on Visual Media and Interactivity builds a contact point for DARIAH members that are interested in visual media and interactivity. The working group intents to stimulate the exchange of best practicesRead more

  • DARIAH-EU Coordination Office Completed

    By dariah

    With the appointment of Mike Mertens as chief executive officer (CEO) the DARIAH Coordination Office (DCO) is now complete. DARIAH-EU’s new DCO With the appointment  of Mike Mertens as chief executive officer (CEO) the DARIAHRead more

  • DARIAH Theme 2015: DARIAH-BE “Open History – Sustainable Digital Publishing of Archival Catalogues of Twentieth-Century History Archives

    By dariah

    by Veerle Van den Daelen (DARIAH-BE) As contemporary historians start to investigate the possibilities and opportunities that digital humanities can offer, a major obstacle for them to do so is that the collection-holding institutions faceRead more

  • DCDC15: DARIAH-EU’s CEO Mike Mertens speaks on „Heritage Collections and the Sustainability of the Digital Humanities“

    By dariah

    DARIAH-EU’s CEO Mike Mertens is part of a pannel on „Digital Humanities“ at RLUK’s DCDC Conference. DARIAH-EU’s CEO Mike Mertens is part of panel 9 „Digital Humanities“ at Research Libraries UK’s (RLUK) DCDC 15 Conference.Read more

  • European Commission Validated an Amendment to the DARIAH-ERIC Statutes

    By dariah

    The European Commission validated an amendment to Annex II, paragraph 2 of the DARIAH-ERIC Statutes. The European Commission validated an amendment to Annex II, paragraph 2 of the DARIAH-ERIC Statutes. The changes concern contributions asRead more

  • „The Emergence of the Digital Humanities in Ireland“

    By dariah

    James O’Sullivan, Órla Murphy and Shawn Day published a paper on DH in Ireland, in which they also write about the role of DARIAH. James O’Sullivan, Órla Murphy and Shawn Day published a paper onRead more

  • DARIAH-RS Launch: The Talks are Online

    By dariah

    Last month DARIAH-RS was launched in Belgrade. The talks can be watched online. Last month DARIAH-RS was launched in Belgrade. The talks can be watched online. Most of them are in Serbian. But central messagesRead more

  • Important DARIAH and Humanities at Scale (HaS) Meetings This Week

    By dariah

    This Week sees three important DARIAH-ERIC meetings and a first Humanities at Scale (HaS) gathering. All four meetings will take place in Berlin. This Week sees three important DARIAH-ERIC meetings and a first Humanities atRead more

NextPrevious

RECENT POSTS

  • New post on DARIAH Open: Open Science in the Horizon Europe funding programme: what to expect?

    In the last DARIAH Open post for 2020, our Open Science Officer Erzsébet

    11 January, 2021
  • Recap of the DARIAH Virtual Annual Event 2020

    The DARIAH Virtual Annual Event 2020 was different than any other of our

    22 December, 2020
  • Seasons’ Greetings from DARIAH-EU!

    On behalf of the DARIAH-EU team, we wish you and your loved

    21 December, 2020
  • Open Call for Proposals: New Languages for NLP training by Princeton University

    Do you wish you could do large-scale text analysis on the languages

    21 December, 2020
  • Step-by-Step: the OpenAIRE-DARIAH Research Community Gateway

    This post is republished from OpenAIRE. In collaboration with OpenAIRE, DARIAH – the pan-European

    15 December, 2020

TWITTER UPDATES

  • RT @ttasovac: We’ve just finished the second part of a meeting of the @DARIAHeu WG “Lexical Resources” together with @elexis_eu partners on…2 days ago
  • Register to the IIIF4Research @IIIF4R Introduction Workshop 2021 on the International Image Interoperability Framew… https://t.co/RB773LaXtz2 days ago
  • Interesting CfP for GLAM professionals&researchers as part of the @Networks2021 Conf,July 6-11 2021 in Washington D… https://t.co/Ydu3O27NTR3 days ago

Tags

ADHO DARIAH Annual Event DARIAH Annual Event 2017 DARIAH Theme DESIR DH H2020 project SSH Open Marketplace Training
Logo of DARIAH
Follow us on:  twitter   youtube   flickr

Contact DARIAH

Email DARIAHinfo@dariah.eu

Privacy and Legal

  • Legal Notice
  • Privacy Notice

Quick Menu

  • DARIAH in a Nutshell
  • Members and Cooperating Partners
  • Projects
  • Events Calendar
  • Helpdesk

Subscribe to our mailing list and newsletter

* = required field
Creative Commons Attribution (CC BY) licence
  • About
    • DARIAH in a Nutshell
    • Mission & Vision
    • Organisation and Governance
    • Join DARIAH
    • History of DARIAH
    • Documents
    • Publications
  • Network
    • Members and Partners
    • Regional Hubs
    • People
  • Activities
    • Working Groups
    • Training and Education
    • Open Science
      • DARIAH Open
      • OpenMethods
      • Heritage Data Reuse Charter
    • Projects
    • DARIAH Theme
  • Tools & Services
    • Tools and Services
    • Contributions
  • News & Events
    • News
    • Events Calendar
    • Annual Events
    • Newsletters
DARIAH
This website uses cookies to improve your experience. We'll assume you're ok with this, but you can opt-out if you wish. Find out more.